From
1:24:06 to 1:25:30 in Christian Carion's The
Girl from Paris we see Adrien talking Sandrine down because she said
she wants to take a break from the farm. Adrien immediately goes into a defense
mode and tells her, "This is not a woman's job ... it requires courage,
muscular strength, constancy ... women change their minds like they change
their clothes." Instead of sympathizing with her and realizing that she
might be a little tired or needs to visit her mom or has genuine reasons to
take a vacation, he starts to belittle her and say that he should have never
sold the farm to her because she does not deserve it. Adrien failed to
acknowledge any of the good that Sandrine had done on his farm, and instead
chose to be childish and try to hurt her because his own feelings would be hurt
with her departure.
I also think it's interesting to
note that Adrien, along with many other older individuals in the society, are
not only struggling with Sandrine as an independent woman running a farm on her
own, but instead are having problems accepting change of any sort. Change to
them is such a foreign concept that they talk down any and everyone who tries
to do something different. We see Adrien's frustration and disappointment in
Sandrine updating the hotel. He can't seem to focus when working in his garden
as she and her crew hammer away at the existing building and he constantly
complains to Jean when she starts having guests like the school children. When
exclaims, "You should see what she does with the rasberries", you would
think that she stepped on them or neglected them.
1. The Girl from Paris/Une Hirondelle ne fait pas le printemps (dir.
Christian Carion, 2001)
Yes, this argument is certainly valid. Let's keep in mind that the director deliberately chose to portray the characters thus in this work of art and contemplate what message he is ultimately trying to convey. Is it really a man's world after all is said and done?
ReplyDeletep.s. As you'll note on today's discussion questions (n.1) the title of the film is incorrect on your syllabus. You'll want to fix that before final submission of this text at the end of the semester.