After reading
Anna’s blog post, I just have to respond to her criticisms of the feminist
movement and the YouTube video that was shared in our class last week. As a
peace studies major, one of the first things one learns is the distinction
between positive peace and negative peace. Often times, many of us think of
peace as merely the absence of war—and while this is indeed one definition of
peace, the idea of positive peace stems from the concept of not only a lack of
physical violence, but a lack of structural violence as well. Indeed, I would
argue that although the United States today is a relatively peaceful country in
the sense that we do not have a war raging on our grounds, it continues to
greatly suffer from structural violence and inequalities. One of these
structural inequalities is that of women and men. And this is a fact, from
unequal pay wages to a lesser number of female executives to the immediate
attention and respect a man is paid merely for being male. Our country has, of
course, come a long way from the idea of Victorian womanhood in the nineteenth
century, however, there are still steps to be taken.
I agree with
Anna in that the video that was shown to us focused more on the everyday
occurrences of gender inequality, and perhaps not more obvious issues such as
female sex-trafficking in our country, or the lack of access to education for
Islamic women in the Middle East; however, this does not mean that the video
should be disregarded in its entirety. Because while its message came via
Carl’s Jr. commercials, it is a larger reminder that the objectification of and
lack of respect for women exists. And that is a problem. Just the other day, a
friend of mine said that a professor of hers blatantly stated, “I never knew women
had an intelligent thought in their head until I began to teach here.” And
while my friend tried to explain how upsetting this statement is in any
setting, regardless of it being a classroom, there is no changing that this
professor’s thoughts are a direct result of a structural problem in our
society. This is a professor who teaches here at Notre Dame. That’s a problem. Sure,
the video glossed over clips that you may not find very persuasive, but that
video exists to remind you that things like this happen everyday in a country
that exists as a world hegemon, and who has the power to influence cultures
around the world. Sure, it was about ‘our world’, but that does not mean it’s
useless by any means. Sure, we live in the first-world, but that does not mean
we should be content with our surroundings. Anger at our situation is what will
spark action, and that will translate to positive change here and abroad. Not
every campaign seeking to address a social justice issue will capture the issue
in its entirety. But at least the campaign is addressing a small part. While
the content of these campaigns matters only if someone on the receiving end is
incited to take action, let us not forget the importance of these campaigns.
Media and platforms like YouTube are powerful, and we are lucky we live in an
age where we can find videos like the one shown in our class, as well as videos
that address issues abroad. Because these videos inform us and push us out of our seat of apathy and privilege.
Bravo, Tori and thank you for speaking up! What a beautiful and heartfelt, even passionate, blog post! I sincerely hope to stay in touch with you all, because I am so curious to know what you are going to turn into 10 years from now. I hope that you will keep you retain this powerful sense of being able to change the world. As in the eulogy to my mom, where I wrote, "the most interesting thing about human life is not how we live our culture’s determinism but rather how we are infused with its possibilities. As columnist Leonard Pitts wrote in a commemoration of the fiftieth anniversary of the inauguration of President John F. Kennedy—one of our family heroes--“'the lesson wasn’t about what we could do, or how we could do, but ‘that’ we could do, that transformation lived within our hands.'”
ReplyDeleteLive strong and stay in touch.